Extreme Rules: Rey Mysterio vs. Seth Rollins

Eye for an Eye Match
The match can only be won when one competitor extracts an eye of their opponent
– Seth Rollins vs. Rey Mysterio

Yes, if you see the replay, Seth Rollins brought a pair of pliers to the ring for this one.

Rey Mysterio went for a 619 early but Rollins regrouped and fought back. Mysterio went for a hurricanrana but Rollins countered and hit a falcon arrow on the apron.

Rollins brought a kendo stick in the ring and tried to jam in it into Mysterio eye. Rey fought back and was tossed to the outside onto a table. Mysterio called him a “son of a bitch,” with Rollins following for an attack on the outside.

Mysterio threw Rollins into the announce table where he caught his right eye on the corner. Rollins countered with a steel chair to Rey’s back. The match eventually went back into the ring where Mysterio went vintage with his high-flying offense, culminating with a frog splash.

Rollins countered with each going back and forth at the other’s eyes. Mysterio finally hit 619. Rollins sold damage to his eye and Rey capitalized by stomping Rollins’ face on the outside. Rey picks up Rollins and takes his face to the corner of the ring steps, pressing his eye into them. Rollins hits a low blow and ends up kicking him in the face right into the barricade. Rollins still heavily selling damage to his right eye.

Rollins hit a curb stomp on Mysterio on the outside, they wondered on announce if he was unconscious.

The finish saw Rollins force Mysterio’s eye into the corner of the ring steps. He backed off like he was going to kick him and it was discovered that Rey’s eye was “out.” The referee called for the bell while Dominick and help came from the back. Meanwhile, Rollins vomited at ringside.

Winner, Seth Rollins

You can read our complete coverage of WWE’s The Horror Show at Extreme Rules at this link.